After the End by Clare Mackintosh
Published by G.P. Putnam's Sons
Publication date: June 25, 2019
Genres: Book Clubs, Contemporary, Fiction, Literary, Social Issues
Your Local Book Store, Amazon
There are many unimaginable things in life, but one of the worst is being the parent of a dying child. Max and Pip are a couple in love who adore their son Dylan. He’s a happy child, but developmentally a bit slow—he doesn’t talk much and falls down more than most children. Shortly before his third birthday they learn he has a brain tumor. A tumor that’s been causing the damage and when removed causes more. Even worse, it has continued to grow. Their little boy is paralyzed from the neck down and unable to communicate. His condition is deemed terminal and the doctors recommend palliative care only. But it is up to Pip and Max to decide for their little boy. This is Clare Mackintosh’s heartfelt, thought provoking novel, After the End.
It’s not a spoiler to say that Max and Pip differ on what to do for Dylan. In the early chapters of the book, this difference is taken to the courts because the hospital where Dylan is being treated agrees with only one of them. The other parent fights. Quickly enough, there is a decision and from there, Mackintosh splits the novel into two realities with chapters in either Pip’s or Max’s perspective. It makes After the End the ultimate ‘what-if’ novel. It also makes for reading that requires a lot of attention because there is more than one thread to follow. It’s easily given, because what is happening is so compelling, but this is not a book to skim through.
I don’t generally issue caveats about books, but this one has some extremely tough moments. Not physically gruesome, but emotionally. I’ve never been a parent but there were at least two scenes when I felt as if I had been punched in the stomach. It’s to her credit that Mackintosh not only painstakingly relays medical and legal information, but gives the same care to the deeply human aspects of After the End. Even if you enter the novel with staunch opinions on sustaining life or death-with-dignity, she honors each and every emotion. Which makes for heartbreaking reading. Her attention to detail and ensuring that the narratives stay realistic works until the novel’s conclusion.
This means: I’m not sure how it ends. Which, as I thought about it, may be what Mackintosh intended. Max and Pip had an excruciating decision to make. When they differed on what to do for their son it became a public nightmare with both having vicious advocates on their side. The what-if narrative is for our benefit, not theirs. Maybe the point of After the End is it’s no one’s business how this story about a terminally ill, beloved child truly ends.
I’ve seen a lot of buzz about this book. I’m tempted to skip it because of the emotional torture I’m sure it will cause. I wasn’t a huge fan of I Let You Go either.
I think it depends on your mood. It wasn’t as difficult as other novels I’ve read about complicated issues, but it did make me think. It just doesn’t seem like a summer release!
Thoughtful review, Catherine. You made me consider some points I hadn’t thought of. Did you read in the author’s notes the Mackintash had a child that died very young of something similar? Obviously, the jumping off point for this book.
I did see that. It definitely made me think.
This sounds really good. Normally I might read it, but I have some dear friends who lost their daughter and since then I’ve been assigned a couple of books that deal with a child dying and I don’t even feel right posting about it for fear they will see it. It’s silly, because it’s not like they would be “reminded” of her death, they can’t escape the fact, but I just can’t see clear to doing it. I suppose I could read this just for me, but really, what are the odds of that? I’m going to add it to the list, however.
I don’t have any of the circumstances you have right now and I still sections of it difficult. If you did have time to read it without reviewing it, it’s very thought provoking.
It sounds rough, too rough for me. And I liked her debut I Let You Go. Does she leave the ending open-ended? I’m having trouble now with the explosion in Miracle Creek …. & the kids in there.
If Miracle Creek is rough for you, then I think this would be too much. She writes it so real. I don’t have children, but there were moments when I thought ‘how would any parent survive this?’.
I’m totally confused! The last sentence of the book, at the WEDDING OF LARS AND PIP. PIP states: “As the service begins, the room disappears and it’s just me, Max and Grace, and the registrar, making us all a family again.”
Would you please explain this? Am I losing my mind?
Oh no! I’m sure you’re not losing your mind, but I read this so long ago I have no idea what happened at the end. I reread my review, though, and I said I had no idea what happened so maybe that was on purpose? We’re not meant to know?