Published by Grand Central Publishing
Publication date: January 6th 2015
Genres: Coming-of-age, Debut, Fiction
When Kevin’s little brother is killed in a freak accident he and his mother go to her father’s house for the summer to try and recover. Kevin is wracked with guilt about his part in the accident or, at least what his father tells him was his part. His mother is a wraith, the life sucked out of her, leaving her emotionally comatose. Her father lives in Medgar, Kentucky, deep in the Appalachians and it is hoped that getting far away from their home and its memories will give both a chance to heal. The Secret Wisdom of the Earth by Christopher Scotton is both a coming of age story and one that encompasses broader social and economic themes, all bound together by the natural world.
Scotton populates Medgar with an assortment of characters. There are the backwoods farmers and miners who eke out a subsistence life and have no interest in or knowledge of what goes on the larger world. There is the coal company’s family, all of whom has profited mightily from mining and are now embracing the mountaintop removal as a cheaper and more efficient way to get at the coal. This despite the fact that it has not only decimated the landscape of the Appalachians but has also destroyed the local economy. Then there are the landowners who are faced with pressure to sell their land to the coal company but are torn between the money and the destruction of their land. For decades these groups have lived in a quiet acceptance of each other but the summer when Kevin arrives an act of terrible violence throws all their loyalties into question.
The themes in The Secret Wisdom of the Earth may not be the most untouched but Scotton gives them a freshness that makes the novel tremendously appealing. At fourteen Kevin is not only moving through the rapids of the teenage years but is doing so without his father and so his grandfather, Pops, becomes his harbor. The character of Pops is one of the finest in the novel, a man of quiet wisdom and common sense. He takes Kevin and his new friend Buzzy on a trek to the family’s land deep in the woods, forcing them to forego every convenience they’ve grown-up with and rely on their own strength. Even amongst the difficulties they experience the last days of childish joy at the simple things found in nature. By writing of the untouched beauty of the hills and lakes that surround them Scotton highlights just how tragic their loss is. For me, these were scenes so well described they left me with a yearning for nights that are truly dark and so clear you can see the stars. They also meant that when a mystical element was introduced at the same time I found it to be unnecessary and a little disappointing. The realities in The Secret Wisdom of the Earth are more than enough to carry the story. Still, Scotton’s ability to punctuate the serenity of nature against the violence of man makes this a strong debut.
[email protected] says
Great review! I absolutely loved this book — finished it on January 1, so it’s my first book of the year. I think it will end up being one of my favorites of the year. My only disappointment with the book (and it’s minor) is that I wanted to know more about Kevin’s mother. She was practically catatonic throughout most of the book, and then, at the very end, we learn something about her (which I don’t want to reveal here). I wish I had known more about the in-bertween; Scotton did this successfully with Buzzy. Our staff book club chose this for our January book and we’re discussing it in a couple of weeks; I can’t wait to hear everyone’s thoughts.
Lots to discuss in the book! I agree about the mother- that and the mystical stuff did not work so well for me. I’ll be interested to see what everyone says. Will you write about it?
Kerry M says
Ooh, I’m excited to pick this one up! Scotton lives in my current town, and will be at the indie bookshop in my soon-to-be town, so I figured I should be interested for supporting local business alone… that, and I love a good coming-of-age story. And the Appalachian setting is appealing, to boot. Glad to hear it stands up!