Publication date: March 13th 2018
Genres: Debut, Fiction, Literary, New Adult
The whole point of this feature is that it’s for books that did not come together for me, but this is one of the first times I’m doubting myself, because two of the bloggers I know and trust loved Laura & Emma. I did not. I didn’t even like it. I disliked it, but gladly admit that maybe I was in the wrong mood for the novel and am wrong in my assessment. In that spirit, there are links after my review to the bloggers I know who enjoyed the novel.
I requested Laura & Emma because it ticked every box in my ‘oh, this is going to be so good’ reading checklist. Debut? Check. Female author? Check. New York City? Check. Quirky female protagonist? Double check because she’s rich as well. The novel is the story of Laura, a young woman who comes from such wealth that after college she doesn’t even need to look for a job, she just goes to work at one of her family’s foundations in a job they create for her. After an unusual one night stand she’s pregnant and decides to have the baby. Emma. The novel covers both their lives for the next fifteen years.
Laura is an odd blend of earnest and entitled. She seems uncomfortably aware of being in the 1% but again and again in the novel, takes full advantage of her advantages. She has no problem informing her ‘job’ that she wants to work part-time but continue to be paid a full-time salary and to get two months paid summer vacation. What? Either you care or you don’t. She recognizes that she’s entitled, but doesn’t want to own it nor does she want the reverse—to turn away from it and get a real job, making real life decisions. Whenever anything goes the slightest bit wrong, she heads home to live off Mummy and Daddy. Or, to be more specific, to make the family housekeeper/cook babysit Emma whenever Laura needs a break. In fact,
Life was much easier at 136. Dinner was prepared, the house was cleaned when she wasn’t looking, she could pass Emma off to Sandra when she needed a break. After a week, Laura decided that it made sense, at least while Emma was a baby, to stay there…
I’m a big fan of both subtlety and satire and appreciate both, but in Laura & Emma it felt as if there was too much of one and not enough of the other. As in, author Kate Greathead overdosed on subtlety—to the point I couldn’t tell what was humor and what was meant seriously, and held back on the satire, which made what may have been meant as scathing feel completely tone deaf. Just as importantly, I never got any sense of connection between Laura and Emma. She seems to have had her because…why not?
Ultimately, Laura & Emma gave me nothing to hold onto. To the point that I set it down twice, for over almost two weeks, when I was already 80% of the way through, which is almost unheard of for me and not a good sign. Greathead did not create a bond between her characters and my brain. However, after hearing other people’s opinions on the book I did pick it up and finish it ,which was not a great idea because the ending made me furious. I’ve yet to talk to anyone who can tell me exactly what it meant. It confirmed my initial feelings about the book then multiplied them tenfold. And, to quote Forrest Gump, “That’s all I have to say about that.”
Novel Visits
Running’n’Reading
Susie | Novel Visits says
March 21, 2018 at 5:51 amThe end of you review had me laughing out loud. Thanks for that and also thanks for the link. As you know, the ending didn’t work for me either, but as for the rest, I think I was in a space where I just appreciated the dichotomy that was Laura.
Catherine says
March 23, 2018 at 10:53 amWe need to talk offline about the ending because Sarah and I had completely different thoughts!
Allison says
March 21, 2018 at 7:52 amI’m bummed to hear you didn’t like this one! I’ve been looking forward to it because of its comparisons to Gilmore Girls–even knowing that I probably won’t like the ending. I’ll still probably give it a try, but I think it’s moving down my list a bit. Hope your next read is more satisfying!
Catherine says
March 23, 2018 at 10:52 amI hope you checked out the two links I included- I think their response was more typical. For some reason it hit me wrong and in a way that snowballed, so I was less tolerant.
Jennifer says
March 21, 2018 at 11:07 amI’m currently reading this book myself. I’m kinda torn between liking and not liking it. It is a writing style I normally do not tend to favor. Though after reading bloggers comments regarding the ending I will finish it.
Tara says
March 26, 2018 at 10:30 amCatherine, thanks so much for sharing my review; I hate to hear that this one was such a drag, but I can completely get behind the idea that reading this novel is all about timing. I can envision a situation in which I would not be able to finish this book…possibly right now, because I have a lot going on and I’m finding it difficult to stay engaged. It’s a *unique* read, let me say that; I also can relate to your description of the ending because…hmm.
Catherine says
March 26, 2018 at 6:19 pmYou’re welcome! I got what you said about the book. For whatever reason, it didn’t strike me that way so I’m pretty sure it was me!
Charline says
December 4, 2018 at 4:17 pmI thought this book was tedious. I could not find much to like about the characters and their dreary lives. As for the ending, huh?
Catherine says
December 5, 2018 at 9:27 amAgreed!