Published by Simon & Schuster
Publication date: August 21, 2018
Genres: Contemporary, Debut, Fiction, Social Issues
I don’t focus on writing negative reviews, but at the same time, when a new novel is getting a lot of hype, my reading friends want to know what I think about it. In this case the novel is Stephen Markley’s debut, Ohio. If all you need is a one sentence opinion then here you go: The novel is a grim mash-up of the plot from 13 Reasons Why and the setting of Hillbilly Elegy and I’d advise reading either of them over this book.
Ohio centers around four classmates in New Canaan, Ohio and is split between two timelines—the present and high school. Bill, Dan, Stacey, and Tina all moved in similar circles, namely those of athletes and their girlfriends, with Markley visiting them in their high school personas and where they are now. Which is nowhere good, as the plot circles around the mystery of sexual abuse suffered by one of the characters, blackmail, the disappearance of another friend, and murder.
My initial problem with Ohio is Markley’s love of descriptors. Take this paragraph from the first chapter:
He spent a couple of minutes freeing all this handiwork, peeling at gobs of tape that lacquered his finger, plucking drunkenly at knots, marveling at how the black configurations of an internal combustion system could look like the phantasmagoric dream-empire likely ruled by a barbaric autocrat.
What should be a straightforward explanation of a character’s actions is lost in baroque prose that seems designed to show off his mad vocabulary skills. Throughout Ohio the reader is bludgeoned with excessive words, which is sad because, stripped down this is a brutal story, one that should be told in the starkest of tones, not tarted up with extraneous words.
Which leads me to whether the story should be told. Markley takes the worst of the worst in today’s news, from CTE, sexual assault, the loss of manufacturing in America, to crime, political corruption, the meth crisis…name it and one of the characters in Ohio has dealt or is dealing with it. I don’t mean to be glib, this novel is the fictional equivalent of the socio-economic situation in Hillbilly Elegy, and should not be taken lightly. Which isn’t even possible because Markley has a lead foot and is pressing the accelerator all the way down, from the novel’s opening scene where one young man is being honored for dying in Iraq to the bleakest high school reunion I’ve ever heard about to an act of revenge that is stunningly horrendous. It’s all too much.
I would not recommend the novel unless you’re looking to sink into darkness without hope, because there is no redemption or peace to be found in Ohio. If you’re ready or interested in exploring the worst of teenage America then the story may scratch that itch. The characters range from average teenage angst to flat out evil—and they don’t change much as they get older. Coupled with overblown prose this was a poor reading choice on my part.
Sarah's Book Shelves says
August 24, 2018 at 4:40 amYES! I’ve been waiting for this review! This sums it up perfectly “bludgeoned with excessive words.” I will say that the first chapter (or Prologue? Can’t remember) with the funeral and parade was excellent…then everything came to a screeching halt.
Catherine says
August 25, 2018 at 1:08 pmHa! Glad you enjoyed. I still have no idea why I finished it. I know there are brutal truths out there, but he opted to roll them all into one book and then shovel a ton of words on it. Not good.
Renee (Itsbooktalk) says
August 24, 2018 at 7:32 amWell, you’ve summed up very nicely why this was a DNF for me before the end of the first chapter! I felt there was way too much descriptive “fancy” prose and rather than impress me it made me put the book down. Thanks for your honest review!
Catherine says
August 25, 2018 at 1:06 pmWise choice. I’m still not sure why I finished. I like fancy sometimes, but then the plot became emotionally and physically gruesome. It was gratuitous. Just ugh.
Susie | Novel Visits says
August 24, 2018 at 8:01 amOuch! I’m so glad I skipped Ohio. I read the description many times, but could never bring myself to request it. It was also on the long side, and long books I need to be pretty sure about. Thanks for being so honest with your thoughts. It really is a big help to other readers.
Catherine says
August 25, 2018 at 1:14 pmYou don’t need this one at all. The plot reminded me of Girls Burn Brighter- the violence and degradation felt gratuitous. And the length was unnecessary.
Allison says
August 24, 2018 at 8:14 amWow, I’ll definitely give this one a pass! It’s too bad, because the premise might have drawn me in. I generally like books that revisit friends from school in adulthood. But it sounds like just too much of everything.
Gayle Weiswasser says
August 24, 2018 at 12:12 pmWow, I’ve heard so many mixed things about this one. Great review.
Catherine says
August 25, 2018 at 1:02 pmIt needed to be one or the other- either brutal story with lean writing or light story with excessive style. It was both and was way too much for me.
Lauren says
August 29, 2018 at 10:12 amGreat review, Catherine.
Catherine says
August 29, 2018 at 4:34 pmThanks. I got a bit cranky.
Lauren O'Brien says
August 30, 2018 at 11:17 amWell, you know that’s one reason it appealed to me.
Catherine says
September 1, 2018 at 12:48 pmI know! Sometimes I wish I could be the light, cheery optimist, but I don’t see it happening. Not in this country right now. I can’t build a bubble big enough to not know/care what’s happening.