Published by Atria Books
Publication date: October 9, 2018
Genres: Fiction, Historical
Time passes differently when I’m alone in the house; I have no way of marking the years. I am aware that the sun continues to rise and set and the moon to take its place, bu I no longer feel its passage. Past, present, future are meaningless; I am outside time. Here and there, there and here, at once.
In present day London, Elodie is an archivist who comes across a leather satchel containing a portrait of a beautiful young woman. Over one hundred years earlier 7-year-old Lily is an orphan taken off the London streets by an avaricious woman who grooms her as a thief. When she is a teenager she catches the eye of Edward Radcliffe, a wealthy artist who pays her to be his muse—a situation her employer encourages until she becomes something much more. These two women, are the living center of Kate Morton’s The Clockmaker’s Daughter, but it is Birchwood, a manor in the English countryside, that is the sun in the novel’s universe. A sprawling cast, seemingly unrelated, orbit around it, as the house waits for its mysteries to be uncovered.
And what mysteries they are. There are Elodie’s discoveries which also includes a drawing of Birchwood, a place she feels is familiar, but which she doesn’t know contains a multitude of unanswered questions. Namely, those about an idyllic summer when a group of artists and friends gathered that ended with one woman dead, another vanished, a priceless gem stolen, and a man’s career destroyed and his heart broken. It’s a lot, but what Morton does consistently and so well is create an alternate world where immersion in a story is completely possible. In The Clockmaker’s Daughter the cast includes friends, artists, school girls, relatives, musicians, World War II evacuees, historians, enemies…all written with the same level of care and attention. They live and breathe on the page, as do their stories.
Despite the numerous narrators and expanding, shifting plot in The Clockmaker’s Daughter there is no problem with confusion. Morton shepherds her readers carefully through her novels, and given their size and scope, it’s appreciated. However, in this case she is like one of those dear old friends who tells great stories, but sometimes embellishes them too much. There are so many back stories and ancillary characters that Morton’s innate attention to detail left me a little weary. She deftly juggles it all, but her desire to neatly tie up all the many threads she’s used makes for a knot tight enough to strangle. There is resolution all around, but in some cases, it feels forced. Something I haven’t noticed before in her other novels. The Clockmaker’s Daughter is still great escapist reading and perfect for gloomy, cold days, it’s just fell a bit short of my high expectations.
Jan says
October 15, 2018 at 6:57 amThoughtful review Catherine. You’d think at 500 pages the author would have been able to tie things up satisfactorily, right? One a book gets over 350 pages it has to be excellent for me to have the patience for it.
Catherine says
October 15, 2018 at 9:11 amWell, she does tie everything up but there is so much that it feels forced- if that makes sense. Every single character, every item and she wraps them all up and it feels forced. Still, that was the very end of the book so for the most part I loved the rest of it. Her stories are so good!
Andrea says
October 17, 2018 at 9:58 pmGlad to hear you enjoyed it! I just pulled the trigger to get it from BOTM and used up some of my remaining credits there
Catherine says
October 18, 2018 at 5:26 pmI hope you enjoy it! She really does a marvelous job pulling together disparate plots and characters.
The Cue Card says
October 18, 2018 at 6:28 amShe’s highly readable. I’ve only read one of hers: The Forgotten Garden (speaking of long books in your previous post). But I agree she should do less wrapping up at the end, and more just letting it go. Still I imagine a good escape read.
Rory says
October 18, 2018 at 9:10 amKate Morton novels are always a good escapist fiction. I am reading this one right now, though I’m early on still.
Catherine says
October 18, 2018 at 5:24 pmShe really does create entire worlds- which is nice when you want to get away from this one!
Amanda says
October 19, 2018 at 1:21 pmThanks for the reminder to get this on the library list! Looking forward to reading.