Honor by Thrity Umrigar
Published by Algonquin Books
Publication date: January 4, 2022
Genres: Book Clubs, Fiction, Contemporary, Cultural
Bookshop, Amazon
When Smita arrives in Mumbai she thinks she’s there to help a good friend undergoing surgery. Otherwise, even as a global journalist, she has never returned to the country her family left when she was a teenager. Now, in Thrity Umrigar’s new novel, Honor, she’s forced to confront her past while coming face-to-face with another young woman horribly impacted by the same forces in the present.
Meena is the other narrator in Honor and she is Smita’s opposite. From a small rural village, she is illiterate and desperately poor. Her world is controlled by men, namely her brothers. That is until she falls in love with and marries a Muslim. As Hindus this brings such shame to her brothers, they set her home on fire, killing her husband and disfiguring and maiming her. Meena now lives with her mother-in-law who blames her for her son’s death. With no resources or allies she still makes the extraordinary decision to bring charges against her brothers, despite the police having no interest in the case.
It turns out Smita’s friend doesn’t need her help in Mumbai, but wants her to cover the story’s verdict when it’s announced. This forces Smita to leave the relative security of a major cosmopolitan city for the utterly unfamiliar world of villages, where life is still lived as it was 20 years ago. Religion and the patriarchy rules, corruption is rampant all of which breeds violence; most often in the name of honor and most often perpetrated against women.
Smita travels with Mohan, a Mumbai native, who, as a man, offers the protection and language skills she needs. At the same time, she chafes against the implication that she can’t handle the situation on her own. Mohan’s love of India grates on her as well so much of their time in the car is spent sparring over her distaste for her homeland. Her arguments are reinforced by the behavior of the many men they come in contact with who will not let her register for a hotel room or will not speak to her directly, but they are contradicted by Mohan who shows her respect and pushes back against her treatment.
All of this could make Honor feel like a one-note, polarizing novel about the evils of fundamentalism in any faith and East versus West, but Umrigar is too gifted a writer to settle on the surface. Instead, as the novel progresses, she uses the lives and backgrounds of two women who are foreign to each other to illustrate the many true meanings of honor, from a father making a shocking decision for his family, to the promise made between women, to the courtship of Meena and Abdul, with its tender propriety and the depth of his respect for her.
Honor blends plot with character in a way to satisfy both readers who like more literary fiction and those who want more movement. Umrigar provides nuanced insight into two very different mindsets—Indian and American, but in a way that exposes the similarities we may not want to see. The same goes for the way she uses the word honor. One small word, but freighted with so much meaning and so easily abused. The brutality that transpires in the village is all done in the name of honor, but makes a mockery of the word. It’s nothing more than generations of unchecked male ego.
It’s in the uneducated, unsophisticated Meena that Umrigar illuminates the true meaning of honor. Both Smita and Meena fully occupy their stories, but even though Meena is a simple woman I found her narrative to be the most profound. Her moral code and inner strength are extraordinary. The intensity of emotion in Honor flows through her and off the page making her character and Honor a novel I’ll not soon forget.
This post contains affiliate links which means if you click on a link and make a purchase, I get a small commission (at no cost to you).
*I received a free copy of this book from Algonquin Books in exchange for an honest review.*
I was wondering if this novel would be too dark a read … but perhaps the inner strength of Meena is enough to keep me afloat … and not leave me wallowing in the violence. What do you think …. is it overly harsh and bleak … or is there more? thanks. I have read a couple of her other novels but perhaps this seems the tensest.
It has scenes of brutality, but Meena and the ending are hopeful.
For me, this was relentlessly bleak throughout.
It was definitely dark, but I found some light in it.
Your reading year is off to a excellent start. This book is getting a lot of buzz. Thank you for your thoughtful review. After reading your review I think this book would not be a good for for me at least not now maybe later.
It’s a lot. I’m finding that many of the winter 2022 releases are dark and challenging. It makes me want to stick with lighter backlist books!
This sounds amazing. I would normally not want to read something like this because I would fear feeling too angry about the injustices and atrocities but it sounds like Umrigar has a nuanced way of portraying the realities. I might have to check it out.
Oh, the injustice is dreadful, maybe worse because it’s ongoing and real, but the story, while dark, doesn’t end that way.
What a gorgeous, gut wrenching novel. I will definitely seek out more from this author. Thank you for bringing it to my attention!
Curious what kept it from being 5 stars for you?
It’s one of those situations I struggle with. I can’t be specific (spoiler), but in the end the main character made a choice I didn’t believe she would make. It’s a little arrogant on my part, but once I’m invested in a character I want them to act as I think they should act. Of course, the author is the one creating so they determine the outcome!
I can definitely see that! It is jarring when characters, especially once we are invested in, act differently than we expect or imagine they would. Would love to hear more of your spoiler-y thoughts on this one!!
As soon as I finished Honor, I came to read your review as I knew you had read it. Your review is beautiful, as I knew it would be. You poignantly unravel everything one could say about this difficult yet wondrous story. This book, and Meena and Abdul in particular, will stay with me for a long time.
Yes- they were so touching. Even as terrified as she was and raised the way she was, he was such a gentleman, he reached her heart. I wish it could have been a happy love story.